Beach to Stay Open to Off-Roaders
> Parks: Coastal panel says rules for Oceano Dunes won't change until
>a study is done. An at-risk bird is at issue.
>
>By KENNETH R. WEISS, TIMES STAFF WRITER
>
>The California Coastal Commission on Wednesday agreed to keep open
>the only beach in Southern and Central California where off-road
>vehicles can race along the water's edge, despite objections from
>environmentalists that the traffic threatens the survival of an
>endangered shorebird.
>
>Before adopting any more restrictions, the commission will wait for
>a panel of advisors to study the dunes near Pismo Beach and
>recommend how to better separate dune buggies and off-road bikes
>from the western snowy plover that nests on the beach.
>
>"The commission decided to go with the status quo," said Chairwoman
>Sara Wan. "We decided to give it a couple of more years and see if
>it can work." The commission's decision comes as the Oceano Dunes
>State Recreation Area, formerly called Pismo Dunes, is preparing for
>the Memorial Day invasion of dirt bikes, sand rails, Jeeps and
>trucks that congregate there every three-day weekend.
>
>Last year, 47,500 people showed up for the long weekend that kicks
>off the summer, and state park rangers expect a similar showing.
>
>Off-roaders from throughout California prefer the magnificent
>seaside dunes in the summer, when other popular off-road
>destinations in the desert get too hot.
>
>Under the Coastal Commission's permit, the state beach limits
>traffic to 4,300 vehicles a day. But the limit is lifted for the
>weekends attached to Memorial and Labor days, July 4 and
>Thanksgiving.
>
>Last November, the Sierra Club sued the California Department of
>Parks and Recreation on grounds that by permitting the beach
>traffic, state officials are causing the deaths of federally
>protected species and destroying their habitat.
>
>In addition to the snowy plover, Oceano Dunes is home to another
>endangered shorebird, the least tern. A creek that off-road vehicles
>must cross to get to the beach has been known to harbor endangered
>steelhead trout.
>
>"It's a shameful embarrassment for the state to allow the imminent
>extinction of the snowy plover," said Mark Massara, director of the
>Sierra Club's coastal program. "Our actions may be too late, but we
>couldn't live with ourselves if we didn't try."
>
>This week, the Pacific Legal Foundation and a group of off-road
>enthusiasts called Friends of the Oceano Dunes sued the U.S. Fish
>and Wildlife Service, arguing that it illegally designated the dunes
>and miles of other coastal areas as "critical habitat" for the
>plovers by failing to consider economic impacts.
>
>"We want to force the government to adhere to Congress' intent, and
>the intent was to consider the effect on people," said Russell
>Brooks, attorney with the Pacific Legal Foundation.
>
>The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service determined that designating the
>area as plover habitat did not result in any economic impact, he
>said.
>
>But his clients maintain that if the beach is closed, it will result
>in the loss of $110 million to the area's economy contributed by the
>more than 1 million off-road enthusiasts who visit San Luis Obispo
>County every year.
>
>"The handwriting is pretty well on the wall for the final order
>shutting down the beach and the dunes," Brooks said.
>
>The suit was filed this week, in advance of the Coastal Commission's
>annual review of the permit for off-road vehicles to use the beach.
>
>Busloads of off-roaders packed the commission hearing in Santa Rosa,
>drawn by e-mail alerts saying the commission would place more of the
>beach off limits or close it to vehicles altogether.
>
>Although the commission has the power to do so, such an action was
>not on the agenda.
>
>Instead, the board kept the same restrictions as last year, which
>limits off-road vehicles to about a third of the 3,500-acre state
>park.
>
>Fewer than 1,000 plovers, a once-abundant shorebird, remain in
>California. A biologist found nests of 33 pairs in 2001 at Oceano
>Dunes, one of the few nesting grounds in the state not lost to
>development.
<font color=yellow>Paige<font color=yellow>